Skip to content

Antony Antoniou – Luxury Property Expert

Challenging the Viability of Heat Pumps in Scotland – A Supplier’s Perspective

Challenging the Viability of Heat Pumps in Scotland – A Supplier’s Perspective


In a move to combat climate change and reduce carbon emissions, the Scottish National Party (SNP) and Scottish Green Party have set ambitious plans to replace gas boilers with heat pumps in Scotland. However, the proposal has sparked controversy, with one major heat pump supplier, Lord Willie Haughey, voicing concerns about their suitability for Scotland’s cold climate. As the owner of a heat pump company, Lord Haughey challenges the effectiveness, practicality, and cost of implementing this green initiative. In this blog post, we delve into the debate and explore the intricacies of using heat pumps as an alternative to gas boilers in Scotland.

The Heat Pump Supplier’s Perspective

Lord Willie Haughey, a prominent business tycoon and Labour peer, is an influential figure in the heat pump industry. He has criticized the SNP-Green plans, arguing that the Scottish climate poses significant challenges for heat pumps to function optimally. According to Lord Haughey, the efficiency of these heating systems drops drastically in freezing weather conditions, making them unsuitable for some regions in Scotland.

The Cold Climate Challenge

Scotland experiences severe winters, with some areas reaching extremely low temperatures, as seen in the -15C recorded last winter. Lord Haughey points out that certain heat pump units might cease to function effectively when the mercury drops to -5C (23F). Additionally, they may require more electricity to maintain proper operation, leading to higher utility bills for consumers.

Noise and Water Heating Capacity

Another concern raised by Lord Haughey is the noise generated by heat pumps. He claims that if multiple neighboring homes had heat pumps installed, the collective noise could become a nuisance, rattling windows and causing discomfort.

Moreover, he highlights that heat pumps only heat water to 54C (129.2F), falling short of the Health and Safety Executive’s recommended temperature of 60C to eliminate legionella bacteria. This raises concerns about public health and safety, as legionnaires’ disease can thrive in water systems with lower temperatures.

Environmental Ratings and Costs

Patrick Harvie, a Scottish Green minister, proposed that homes using gas boilers should receive lower environmental ratings. The plan aims to push for higher energy efficiency and reduce dependency on fossil fuels. However, Lord Haughey argues that the cost of installing heat pumps is significantly higher than that of conventional gas boilers. While the 2021 government strategy estimated an average cost of £10,000, Lord Haughey states that it has risen to £15,000, making it less financially feasible for homeowners.

The Science Behind the Heat Pump Debate

Lord Haughey challenges Patrick Harvie to a debate on the scientific merits of heat pumps. While he acknowledges the importance of eco-friendly initiatives, he maintains that heat pumps are less efficient in Scotland compared to other countries due to the colder climate.

The Government’s Stance

In response to the criticism, a Scottish government spokesman highlights the urgent need to tackle climate change, as about 20% of Scotland’s carbon emissions come from heating buildings. By transitioning to energy-efficient and renewable alternatives like heat pumps, the government aims to reduce costs, decrease reliance on fossil fuels, and mitigate the impact of climate change in the long run.


The debate surrounding the replacement of gas boilers with heat pumps in Scotland is far from settled. Lord Willie Haughey’s perspective sheds light on the practical challenges and concerns associated with implementing this green initiative. While heat pumps offer environmental benefits, their effectiveness in colder climates and the associated costs remain contentious issues. As the dialogue continues, policymakers must carefully consider scientific evidence, economic implications, and public opinion to strike a balance between sustainability and practicality in the pursuit of a greener future.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments